We have had a Berkey for years, we have 4 of them with never an issue. Many thanks in advance for your reply. So Id appreciate your feedback on Radiant Life as well. Hi! most can filter water from streams, ponds, pools, etc. From what I have read, Berkey, AquaRain, Propur, and Alexapure filters are interchangeable. Hi Jay, Ive been using this system for about 1 year: https://www.ebay.com/itm/EHM-Alkaline-Mineral-Water-Ionizer-Pitcher-Filter-2-5L-Pure-Healthy-Water-EHM/112063550047?var=&hash=item1a1782125f. I think itll answer any questions you might have. When I originally went to Berkeys website to buy their system, I found they are completely out of stock due to the current coronavirus panic, and Berkeys website does not state when they will get more inventory in. What made you think that your water quality is poor and needs to be improved? Note: Sodium fluoride, hexafluorosilicate, and fluorosilicic acid are all forms of fluoride found in drinking water. To remove sodium, youll need to use a reverse osmosis system or a water distiller. This is a brand that my family and I have been using for many years. Biggest Complaints:Knob on lid is hard to install; not great at removing radioactive contaminants. But we can read, and we have brains, so we can take the information that's available and try to make a reasonable choice. While the Alexapure Pro is a fine water filter made from quality materials, it just cant match the decades-long track record of excellent service and reliability that Berkey has. Great information. Thank you for all of your hard work! **, 1 year for ceramic filter;6 months for 5-stage filter. Lifetime on stainless steel parts; 12 months on filters. Filter Life:3,000 gallons, or about 3 to 5 years for Black Berkey filters; 1,000 gallons, or about every 6 months for fluoride filters. I asked the manufacturer if filtering with the Propur G2.0 filter changes the pH. Just starting to look into this and wondering if you have any advice or direction specifically related to well water? Do you know of any whole house gravity filtration systems Or one that we'd be able to connect to our waterline? The filter element is made in the US, and the housing is made in India. Another reason is that they are portable and you can attach them with any of your home faucets with the right adapters. The customer service reps blamed our water company, blamed us, and again did everything they could to get our of helping us. There is no way their filters last 3-5 years (or 6000 gallons of water). Lab test results published in September 2017 show a 99.99% reduction in microplastics. This is just one of several sizes available from ProOne USA and is comparable to the Big Berkey. Thank you for your hard work! The newer G2.0 design has a blue base (not gray). 2. Although AlexaPure is more affordable, there isnt much difference in the price of both the filters. The Safe Healthy Home is reader supported. Some Berkey products are available in California, but not all are. Both the Alexapure Pro and Berkey filters have nesting stainless steel bodies, removable filter elements, and very few parts that can wear out. By contrast aluminum oxide is not water-soluble; it is inert, is very stable and is not associated with negative health effects. Filter and mineralize your water with a gravity filter system from Zen Water. After seeing the visible growth of both these filters, our experts decided to compare them to see how they are similar and what the factors that make them different are. Thanks for your input! Filtration methods that do remove the good minerals are reverse osmosis and distillation. My understanding is that the silver used in the filters is not intended to disinfect the water, but rather is used to prevent bacteria from growing in the filters themselves. Theres no mention of it at all in the description. I mean: Its 2 stainless steel buckets and a lid with holes in it. Looking at the contaminant reduction table, you can see that it's quite good at removing contaminants. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Thank you! You can even put them in the dishwasher if you so desire. We never had a problem with their filters until about 6 months ago when I bought replacement filters.

As a consumer, its important to know that pure aluminum and aluminum oxide have vastly different characteristics. That's a given. Sometimes they have special sales and bundle deals, plus they offer two larger system sizes - 6 gallon and 8 gallon. Warranty:30 day return policy on unopened products.

I assume youre referring to the Berkey PF-2 fluoride filters. The housing has been slightly modified, but the filter technology is the same. I certainly would. We live in the midwest with lots of agricultural byproducts in our well water. Thanks! Hi, have you heard of the AquaCera Stoneware gravity water filter system? Spent thousand on filters too. It is going to make your water taste better, and it will remove some contaminants. The link that you mentioned is actually not the manufacturer. Also, Only sales of the followingoutdoorsystems and products are now available to customers in the state of California: Sport Berkey,Go Berkey,Travel Berkey,BerkeyLight (With or without LED lights), Black BerkeyFilter Elements, PF-2 Fluoride Filters, and All Replacement Parts. So apparently all the replacement parts and filter elements themselves are approved. Without carbon, it cant remove chemical or organic contaminants. Also: The solid Carbon Block filter (Berkey) seems extremely over-priced.

Doing thorough research on each product will help you greatly in making the right choice. Water is the source of life, but it can take it away from you. So once added is it considered fluoride in the water at that point or is it still hydrofluorosilicic acid(HFS)? Theyre more expensive than many other water filter options, but theyre easier to use, more robust, and can filter a vast amount of water before you need to switch out filters. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Critical towards choosing the best product and honest with my feedback. It's a bit weak in lead reduction, though - only 96.4%. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. I purchased a Big Berky last week from Amazon. I realize you do it selflessly and simply for the joy of helping others maintain perfect health. Warranty: 30 day return policy if damaged or defective on arrival. I read the specifications on their website and are greatly impressed. 12 months on System and PF-2 filters; 2 years on Black Berkey filters. But in terms of structural integrity and effectiveness in removing contaminants, I think that Berkey and ProOne are tied for number one.

Hi, Kim! Josh is a freelance writer and avid outdoorsman. As an added bonus, the ProOne Big+ comes with a 6-inch stainless steel stand to make dispensing easier. Today I spoke with someone at Propur regarding Proone G2.0 filters. I looked specifically at 5 important factors that I look for when determining water filter quality: filter effectiveness, capacity/flow rate, cost of ownership, ease of maintenance, and reliability. If you want to get rid of fluoride, you can buy optional PF-2 fluoride filters to add to the system. The Big Berkey with the full four Black Berkey filter elements provides a 7 gallons per hour flow rate compared to Alexapure Pros 9.2 gallons (with the maximum number of filters). Need help with the fluoride. The system has properly tested and has certified filtration media. Also, the Zen should only be used with potable water -in other words, treated tap water. The Berkey worked for a week and stopped filtering. There's no warranty to speak of on this system. Best to you and have a great day / week!! Thank Mrs Marge Sweigart for an excellent and informative article. The different length filters are for different size systems. We have carefully compiled up a comprehensive buying guide so that you will make an informed and confident decision while buying a water filter for your home. They worked for a few days then back to not working. Some days would be heavy water usage, other days not so much. This is great. The filters themselves can filter a lot of water before a replacement is necessary and so long as you prevent rust the body basically wont wear out. Heres info about Berkey filters: http://berkeywaterkb.com/do-the-black-berkey-purification-elements-have-silver-in-them/. I would think that if there is a problem with a particular system, it is due either to user error or a defective part(s). I asked how many gallons each filter is good for. Best Features: Inexpensive; looks nice; raises pH of the water; easy to use. Why Use a Countertop Gravity-Fed Water Filter? The answer was On average about 700-1200 gallons per filter. {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}. Whereas faucet mount filters need to be removed every time you need to switch to unfiltered water. I.e, Im not stripping the water of its beneficial elements, am I? Alexapure comes with a single carbon block filter encased in a hybrid ceramic shell. I think you could say that the filters should be cleaned to enhance both the function and useful life. Im sure there are health benefits but I would think Id need to be more consistent in using it when cooking as well. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Winner: Tie. I see some online sources (YouTube, Amazon user reviews, etc) saying the filters can and should be CLEANED every six months or sousing some kind of mildly abrasive surface, but Im not sure of the details, and failed to ask the Propur rep. Do you know if they can be cleaned to enhance function and/or extend useful life? Thank you, James! One that doesnt remove all healthy minerals as Zerowater does. Neither brand removes minerals, so you wouldnt need to worry about that. This is the smallest of the available Zen Water systems. Please let me know about the Berkey Discount. For those who want a quick overview, below is our comparison table: Both Berkey and the Alexapure Pro are countertop style gravity-fed water filters. Hi, Karen! I would want to see lab test results before considering purchasing it. However, the general filtration capacity of this filter is 5000 gallons for 5 years. I will add Radiant Life to the list, though. Berkeys are so bad that California wont allow the sale of them for home use. Berkey water filters have been available for decades, and people have been using them every day of those decades without problems. Thats what I would do. First, the body is made of BPA free plastic instead of stainless steel. From what you shared, it is worth investigating.

A water filter will keep you safe from getting sick by drinking dirty and contagious water. No one has the time to waste a whole day just to replace a filter cartridge.

Do you have an opinion on this one? Theres an option for Imperial Cerametrix filters at a higher price. Next up is the ProOne Big+. Unfortunately, it has been shown to contain significant amounts of arsenic and to leach lead from plumbing. They actually don't have any results suggesting they last that long anyway.

Second, it does more than just filter. Those results are included in the contaminant reduction table above. They're not just for preppers anymore! 3. You just put unfiltered water in the top, and gravity pulls the water downward through the filter element(s) and into the holding chamber. If we talk about who is more affordable and who offers more value of money, there is no clear answer. The Berkey sounds great, but I had reservations about using stainless steel for water filtering and storage, based on several articles Ive recently read online about #304 Stainless Steel (used for Berkey) and most other stainless steels, that leach nickel and chromium into cookware, etc. Thanks for doing this. This is a great review. Hi TLQ! Click here to shop for the best gravity water filters at Amazon.

For the most part its great.

So, it seems to be limited in what it can do. The Aquametix filters reduce fluoride, so you dont need any additional filters. Gravity-fed countertop water filters, like the Alexapure Pro or Berkey filters, produce safe drinking water in large quantities from impure sources. I absolutely love the taste of the water, no longer buy bottled water, and would like to get a 4 or 6 gallon system that will enable me to cook with the water as well. IF I understand correctly. Suggested Reading: Should You Worry About Microplastics in Your Drinking Water? I bought a AquaRain system about 5 years ago.

Im not on Facebook anymore, so I cant read what those other folks are saying. I still dont understand the benefit of buying a LONGER filter. I am changing systems and filing a Better Business Bureau complained against the company. The filter comes with a separate fluoride filter for the complete removal of excessive fluoride from your drinking water. Thats my first impression, anyway. Thanks for organizing all this information. We are hopeful that after such a detailed discussion, you have got all the answers you needed.

And this is the main reason why I rated Alexapure a little lower than Berkey and ProOne. Hi, Alex! The useful life of the filter is measured in volume. Wow, E.T., Im sorry youre having this problem. They do state on their website that the filter does not removefluoride. A good thing about buying AlexaPure is that you get more contaminants removal at a lesser price whereas Berkey offers almost the same quality at a higher rate. How well does it compare to Berkey and Propur? Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. The Alexapure Pro is another gravity filter system that's similar to Berkey and ProOne. You can either go directly to the Berkey Filters website or read my post on How to Save Big on a Berkey Water Filter. A pair of Black Berkey filters were a bit more expensive than a single Alexapure Pro filter and provided 6,000 gallons of use vs 5,000 for a single Alexapure Pro filter. Sometimes you can find good deals on Berkey filters bundled with accessories or discounts on add-ons at Berkey Filters, an authorized Berkey distributor. All you need to do is re- prime the filters once and the filter will be clog-free. Heres what Berkey Filters has to say about that: Our PF-2 filters reduce fluoride and arsenic in your water using the media aluminum oxide (aka activated alumina). Im not sure what you mean the glyphosate removal rate in the table is from the manufacturers website. If youre on well water, are traveling in an RV or Tiny Home, or are uncertain about the quality and safety of your city water, either of these filters will provide you with a tested level of protection. Theyre also an excellent option for car camping, RV travel, traveling with a tiny home, or living fully off the grid with a rainwater catchment system. after ten.yes ten replace my sets.and many Videos to prove it wasnt user error, and arguments with the company After they revealed that they do NOT test returned filters to figure out where it was flawedI finally got a set that passed the test.

Im not familiar with that product. It comes with two Black Berkey filter elements, which are made of coconut shell carbon plus a proprietary blend of five other media. AlexaPure Pro has the tendency to catch rust if it isnt cleaned and maintained properly. Gravity Filters Contaminant Reduction Table. That person was NOT a TechSupport rep and the information I received is somewhat confusing.

Hi, MC! Do you have any direction or thoughts on that? Hi, Arica! I can do I either but which one is better? I called millenium and requested replacements (also making them aware that I had also purchased Flouride filters and hoped theyd be ok) I was sent replacing after replacement ALL OF WHICH FAILED RED DYE TEST ON ARRIVAL. Hi, Michael! So I kinda would like a little help with the functioning / usage needs and what do you know about Kangenif at all possible. Installed them this past weekend, its been less than a week and the new filters have stopped filtering again. It would be interesting to see how these gravity systems compare side by side, but that would require a lot more work. If Berkey is so great, why doesnt it have certification? The filter life of your filters is mentioned in the instruction manual. Go through it and replace them when the given gallon limit is reached. The Amazon link you provided for AquaCera shows only one ceramic model thats unavailable, dont know when/if it will be available again. That doesn't seem too bad, but keep in mind that, according to the EPA, there is no safe level of lead in drinking water. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Really depends on the specific water chemistry of the source water. At their website, it says that they recommend replacing the filters every 6 to 12 months, depending on which size system/filters you are using. The CeraMetix were updated earlier this year and now the core is the AquaMetix block which is significantly better than the granular form we used to provide. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Berkey filters have gone through extensive testing by independent labs, and are very effective at removing mostkinds of contaminants. Find informative recipe tips, kitchen items, restaurants, and water filter reviews by experts. They also have deep discounts on scratch and dent models. Here we are a year later and one filter is failing.

Very informative. Thanks for your input. And what do you need with a Berkeydoes it not come with a spout? Hi, Katie! Question: dont silver-impregnated filters leak silver into the water, and isnt silver toxic? Warranty: Lifetime on stainless steel parts; 12 months on filters. However, I am looking for a smaller gravity filtration system thats around a gallon that would go on my counter and or refrigerator. Removes up to 99.9999% of 200+ water impurities, including lead, bacteria, viruses, cysts, Groundbreaking gravity block core filter with hybrid ceramic shell. Im curious what company have you been buying the filters from? Finally, we've got the least expensive of the filters in this review: the Zen Water System Model 4G-MP. AlexaPure Pro does remove traces of fluoride, but it doesnt come with a separate fluoride filter for proper removal. It's manufactured by an American company called Alexapureand is sold through several online retailers. Nope. We would love a share . Hello, Do any gravity counter top water filters that you know of remove glyphosates as well? One problem you run into doing this comparison is that identical tests were not run on each of the systems. 5in, 7in and 9in filters are available, and the longer filters are supposed to provide a longer useful lifeMAYBE. So I bought another two Berkey filters, same thing and last week I purchased another set(my third in 6 months at $104.00 for the set). You can shop at Zen Water by clicking here. My primary concern is FLUORIDE, but the more I learn about drinking water the broader my range of concerns becomes. On the other hand, AlexaPure offers only 45- days warranty; that too for as long as it is packed. Not all filters offer the exact value of money, sometimes you buy expensive products that end up being wasted. Im so done with berkey. Cerametix does everything that Aquametix does, plus it reduces biological contaminants. A 1-year warranty is an average warranty that comes with a countertop water filter. Hi, Tom! We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The steel containers are sturdy and the filter really does clean the water better than any other system I have used.

Thanks! They take PayPal, too, if that's how you prefer to pay. The filter elements themselves are manufactured in the US, and the stainless steel housing is assembled in the US. If you have any questions, feel free to leave them in a comment below, and I'll get back to you asap. Not for drinking water, anyway. Do I understand your chart is suggesting ProPur would be the better selection for my city? So, if you are not the type of person to constantly maintain your filter, go for the highest filter life.

Ive never heard of Ultraceram or Stefani Aquaramic. The numbers in the table tell you how much the contaminants were reduced during the test. PS to my recent comment re: AquaCera The cream-colored ceramic model, not available on Amazon, is available at the WaterCheck.biz website. The ceramic filter and 5 stage filter system, removes the nasty taste and smell of the water to where it is equal to any bottled water you can buy. Alexapure - above average filtration at a lower cost. HFSA is a form of fluoride, and its the one most commonly used in US fluoridation programs. He graduated from the University of Georgia with a B.A. Get yours at My Patriot Supply. Hi, Eva! Im on well water now, and my last house was also on well water. Many of their filters and plugs leak and allow untreated water to pass through. Is this something that you experienced? I needed to watch a YouTube video to figure out how to set up, which took maybe 30 min to do. I red dye test every 3-6 months. Could you kindly share your opinion about the Radiant Life one too please? Good quality. Countertop filters come in a wide price range. Third place goes to the Zen Water system. Hi Cathy! Email us: [emailprotected]. For more information please see my in-depth review of the Alexapure Pro. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Best Fluoride Water Filters: 2022 Buyers Guide, Comparison Table: Best Countertop Gravity Water Filters, Contaminant Reduction: Berkey vs ProOne (Propur) vs Alexapure vs Zen Water, Big Berkey (most popular gravity water filter), ProOne Big+ (best gravity water filter for lead removal), Alexapure Pro (cheapest stainless steel gravity filter), Zen Water 4 Gallon Filter System (best gravity water filter that adds minerals). I dont understand why, unless the larger filter simply provides greater surface area which takes longer to clog up or wear out or whatever. Contact us at: [emailprotected], Big Berkey Gravity-Fed Countertop Water Filter, 5 Best Countertop Water Filters To Remove 99.99% Of Viruses & Pathogens, 5 Best Off Grid Solar Kits That Wont Break The Bank, Alexapure Vs Berkey Comparison 5 Important Factors, Filter Effectiveness What Contaminants Do They Filter. Read more. What are the benefits of gravity filters? So, if you are looking for crystal clear water in every glass without disrupting your budget, AlexaPure is always a more reliable selection.

Propur and Alexapure show individual results for each of the 3 forms of fluoride, while Berkey and Aquacera have a general fluoride reading. Berkey is by far the best known and most popular brand of gravity filters. That's because lead bioaccumulates in the body. Its really a matter of personal preference. Maybe Ill pull it out, buy some food coloring, and do the test. **This table is best viewed in horizontal orientation on mobile devices. I used to sing from the hills about them as a company but in the last 3 yrs its seemed that the company has lacked in Quality control. I had decided before reading your article to replace our filters with the Propur, and after reading still have the same opinion. At the time Berkeys were having filter leaking problems that they knew of and continued to ship the faulty ones. Are there any filters you would recommend to remove any extra sodium from the water? Want to learn more about gravity water filters and how they work? So, we lovedloved their product. Whichever filter you decide to go with, you can rest easy knowing that theyre effective, affordable, and long-lasting ways to protect your family from unsafe drinking water. But in the past 3 yrs the black carbon filters have failed me after only 2 months! Kudos! The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". Ive owed the berkey royal for 10 yrs. Dirt and other junk from the water will build up on the exterior surface of the filter and slow down or prevent water from being drawn into the filter. We will highly recommend that you look up for countertop water filters instead of faucet mount filters. However, some of the best ones also offer satisfaction trials and money-back guarantees along with the warranty. Due to popular request from our readers, Ive decided to put these filters in a head-to-head comparison if Berkey is still king of off-grid water filtration or if the young upstart, Alexapure, has managed to dethrone it. Im sure theyll know! Pure aluminum is water-soluble, it is highly reactive and it is associated with negative health effects. We didnt use a water softener for either house. Have questions? So, my question is are the filters interchangeable between systems? The main area where it's not as good is in the reduction of radioactive substances. Hi, Steve! It is very helpful. Did you check the prices on all of the systems in this post? AlexaPure Pro Vs Berkey Water Filter Review, FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) on AlexaPure and Bereky. Combined, the Berkey system can easily last for 3 to 5 years with timely replacements and maintenance. I like having the specific numbers like Propur and Alexapure have done. The water tastes great! I found the company that manufactures these: http://www.watercheck.biz; they have a blue stoneware model with two Aquametrix quickdrip filters. These include all the most common pathogenic threats such as e.coli, salmonella, etc, as well as petroleum products, arsenic, lead, and manganese. This is just a note of gratitude. After a while, they'll need to be replaced altogether. Are they sold in the US? No, silver is not leached into the water. No, I dont think there is any such thing. It is an excellent public service. At this point it seems that the Berkey is for me, but how do you determine which one to purchase? Berkey water filter gets slowed and clogged after some months. See also my detailed review of the ProOne filter. I suspect they say that because most people arent going to be aware of how many gallons of water theyre using. Filter Life: 5,000 gallons, or about 5 years. Last update on 2022-07-30 at 11:25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. You really made my day! But, it has a stainless steel spigot instead of plastic. My conversation with Propur suggests the filter should be replaced 6 MONTHS after placing it in service regardless of how much use (how many gallons) it has filtered That doesnt sound right at all. The only thing you need to take care of is to avoid using too hot water for countertop filters. Thanks so much for this info! Thanks for this info.

By themselves, the Black Berkey filters will not remove fluoride. Access the ProOne independent lab test reports here.