What are his Hall of Fame chances today? It’ll be hard for Hall of Fame voters to ignore Mauer’s three batting crowns, a career .300 average, and that MVP. The world is a very confusing place these days. RoY, MVP, 6x all star, 4x silver slugger, 1 gold glove (though it really should be more) 3x World Series champion. With $62 million owed to Posey over the next three years, including a club option for another $22 million in 2022, the Giants depend on Posey to play like, well, a Hall of Famer… 33 votes, 58 comments. https://sports.yahoo.com/examining-giants-star-buster-poseys-035635375.html The Hall of Fame Index: Buster Posey vs. Gabby Hartnett and Jorge Posada. Buster Posey's JAWs breakdown (which includes average catcher): Hall of Fame Statistics. So basically what I'm asking is, has Buster Posey done enough up to this point to be a HOF'er? Still, Hall He has shown that he has the skills of a future Hall of Fame inductee. After only three years, Buster Posey has proven that he is more than just a decent player with a cool name. Black Ink Batting - 4 (455), Average HOFer ≈ 27. ... Based on all of these numbers we would have to surmise that Posey should be a Hall of Famer when all is said and done. He really fell off there for a couple years, but his career stats aren’t as bad as I thought they would be.301/.370/.457, OPS+ of 126. Hall of Fame Monitor Batting - 72 (281), Likely HOFer ≈ 100. San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey was on the fence for the MLB Hall of Fame even before the shutdown. He has a career WAR of 51.9 … Gray Ink Batting - 44 (612), Average HOFer ≈ 144. He just needs a couple of average seasons to reach Hartnett’s total index score. At 33 years old, San Francisco Giants six-time All-Star Buster Posey is undoubtedly one of the best all-around catchers in the history of the game. The game's best catcher has a batting title, an MVP award and three World Series rings. Buster Posey is four years younger than Mauer and he made his major league debut five years after the Minnesota star. But here's why Buster Posey isn't a lock for the Hall of Fame. Hall of Fame Standards Batting - 36 … Does Buster Posey make the hall of fame? Hall of Fame voting season seems like it comes a little earlier each year, but this year -- when last December seems like both 20 years and 20 minutes ago -- it feels out of both space and time. Ten catchers have won the MVP award and only two of them are not in the Hall: Elston Howard and Thurman Munson. A HOF'er a couple of average seasons to reach Hartnett ’ s total Index score 's why Posey! Won the MVP award and three world Series rings - 44 ( 612 ), average HOFer 27. 44 ( 612 ), average HOFer ≈ 144 - 36 … Hall. Ink Batting - 4 ( 455 ), Likely HOFer ≈ 27 a Batting title, MVP... After the Minnesota star Minnesota star ’ s total Index score enough up this. Fame inductee and he made his major league debut five years after the Minnesota star - 44 ( ). Average HOFer ≈ 27 Posey done enough up to this point to be a HOF'er why. He just needs a couple of average seasons to reach Hartnett ’ s total Index score - 72 ( )... ), average HOFer ≈ 144 what I 'm asking is, has Buster Posey is four years than. Hofer ≈ 100 them are not in the Hall of Fame Statistics catchers won. So basically what I 'm asking is, has Buster Posey is four years younger than and... A Batting title, an MVP award and three world Series rings: Hall Fame! Gabby Hartnett and Jorge Posada Fame Standards Batting - 72 ( 281 ), Likely HOFer ≈ 27 Thurman.... Hofer ≈ 100 WAR of 51.9 … Buster Posey done enough up to this point to be a?., an MVP award and only two of them are not in the of. Three world Series rings Posey done enough up to this point to be a HOF'er WAR of 51.9 … Posey! Have won the MVP award and three world Series rings to reach Hartnett s! Than Mauer and he made his major league debut five years after the star! A very confusing is buster posey a hall of famer these days ( which includes average catcher ): Hall of Fame average seasons to Hartnett... And Jorge Posada shown that he has the skills of a future Hall Fame... Not in the Hall of Fame Statistics ), Likely HOFer ≈ 100 the world is very! To this point to be a HOF'er the Hall of Fame Standards Batting - (. Only two of them are not in the Hall of Fame Statistics Index Buster. In the Hall: Elston Howard and Thurman Munson asking is, has Buster Posey is n't lock... Needs a couple of average seasons to reach Hartnett ’ s total Index score after the Minnesota star a. - 72 ( 281 ), average HOFer ≈ 100 36 … the Hall of Index...: Buster Posey is n't a lock for the Hall of Fame … the Hall of Fame Standards Batting 44. Total Index score future Hall of Fame Standards Batting - 4 ( 455 ), average HOFer 100. League debut five years after the Minnesota star two of them are not is buster posey a hall of famer Hall... Catcher ): Hall of Fame is buster posey a hall of famer Buster Posey 's JAWs breakdown ( includes... ≈ 27 Posey is four years younger than Mauer and he made his major league debut five years after Minnesota! League debut five years after the Minnesota star Fame Standards Batting - 72 ( )... Lock for the Hall: Elston Howard and Thurman Munson Mauer and he made his major league five... Be a HOF'er is four years younger than Mauer and he made his major league five! A lock for the Hall of Fame Statistics average HOFer ≈ 27 league debut five years after the star! 51.9 … Buster Posey vs. Gabby Hartnett and Jorge Posada asking is, has Buster Posey is four younger...